Home
    • Home
    • About us
    • Our members
    • Topics
    • Press
    • Projects
    • Get involved
    • Resources
    • Contact

Topics

  • ECRE's Agenda for Europe
  • Access to Europe
  • Asylum in the EU
    • Determining Responsibility (Dublin)
    • Reception of Asylum Seekers
    • Qualifying for International Protection
    • Asylum Procedures
    • Detention
    • Temporary Protection
    • Vulnerable Groups
  • Resettlement
  • Integration
  • Return
  • Protection Beyond Europe
Home >> Topics >> Asylum in the EU

Asylum in the EU

Huge differences exist between national asylum systems in Europe, making the asylum system a 'lottery' for refugees. For this reason, EU countries are working to develop and establish a Common European Asylum System (CEAS).  

The aim of a CEAS is to create a level playing field, where any person seeking protection will be treated in the same way, according to the same standards, wherever they apply for asylum.

The Hague Programme envisaged ‘practical and collaborative co-operation' among Member States as an important step in the process of achieving a Common European Asylum System. According to ECRE, Member States should enhance their practical cooperation through the exchange and application of best practices to ensure EU asylum systems are improved. For these purposes, ECRE would welcome the establishment of a European Asylum Support Office (EASO) if it were well-resourced and founded strongly on principles of democratic accountability and transparency.

ECRE does not support harmonisation for its own sake. However, ECRE supports the creation of a CEAS if it leads to good standards of protection that are in line with international and European refugee and human rights law. Five main legal instruments make up the EU acquis on asylum:

  • Temporary Protection
  • Determining Responsibility (Dublin)
  • Reception of Asylum Seekers
  • Qualifying for Protection
  • Asylum procedures

According to ECRE's assessment, while some measures within these instruments clearly aimed at improving standards, many others unfortunately allowed the lowest possible standards to prevail.

 

ECRE's position
  • The development of a CEAS will only add value if it improves asylum laws, policies and practices in line with the international responsibilities.

  • The result of this process should be that no matter where a person applies for asylum in the EU, he/she will be treated humanely in accordance with international and European refugee and human rights law and will receive the correct decision on his/hers claim.

  • Erecting ever-higher walls around Europe is not the solution and a far more balanced approach is needed.

  • In developing a CEAS Europe should share good practice not bad laws.

ECRE Position Papers
  • Way Forward: "Towards Fair and Efficient Asylum Systems in Europe"

  • Comments on the Proposal for a Regulation establishing a European Asylum Support Office (EASO)

  • ECRE Comments on EU plans to establish a European Asylum Support Office (EASO)

  • Evaluation of EU Minimum Standards on Refugee Protection

  • ECRE Green Paper Response

  • The Promise of Protection: Progress Towards a European Asylum Policy Since Tampere

  • Comments on a more efficient Common Asylum System - the Single Procedure as the next step

ECRE Actions
  • Memorandum to the JHA Council: Guaranteeing refugee protection and safeguarding respect for fundamental rights

  • ECRE presentation at a LIBE Committee Public Hearing on Fundamental Rights in the EU

  • Recommendations to EU Ministers at the Brussels European Council of November 2004

  • Memorandum to the JHA Council: Ending the asylum lottery: Guaranteeing refugee protection in Europe

  • Memorandum to the JHA Council: Practical Cooperation - Improving Asylum Systems

  • ECRE & Amnesty International letter to the Chair of the Strategic Committee on Immigration, Frontiers and Asylum (SCIFA)

Press Releases
  • Call for withdrawal of the proposed asylum procedures Directive

  • Concern at the expected agreement of asylum measures in breach of international law

Other Sources
  • EU Commission: Policy plan on asylum: An integrated approach to protection across the EU

  • EU Commission: The Hague Programme - Ten priorities for the next five years

  • EU Commission: Green Paper on the future Common European Asylum System

  • European Parliament: Report on asylum: practical cooperation, quality of decision-making in the common European asylum system

  • European Parliament: Decision-making in the common European asylum system

  • European Council: Tampere Conclusions

  • Amnesty International: The EU's asylum policy in a securitised world, Irene Khan

  • Human Rights Watch: Backgrounder on EU migration and asylum

  • UNHCR: Comments on EU asylum law and policy

Contact - Disclaimer - Copyright - Site Map